That lead me in the right direction.
Our "Rank Images" have working since I became an admin, and I never bothered to look into it. They just displayed the words of the rank under the rank. It appears that when our forum was setup, the Admin used the full path to the image (which the manual says not to do). Since then, our WebSite moved from .Net to .Com. As long as no one had anything on the .Net site, we just saw the "words". Last night, someone took over the .Net and put a bunch of images called b3.jpg, b4,.jpg, etc. It just so happens those are the names of the Rank Images our forum was looking for.
So, all of our rank images were coming from our old website that has now been taken over by someone else. Weird.