No error, they're just not showing. If you go here: http://neweditionfanclub.com/board/viewtopic.php?t=4077
you'll see. I checked the permissions, they're all 777, I checked the ACP and avatars are enabled except that there is a line asking "Number of posts before user avatar is enabled" and everytime I try to enter something and recheck the configuration the number I put in there never stays.
Also, I installed the Shop Mod (after this problem already existed) and turned off everything in the Effects Shop so that nothing is effected.
I've posted this problem all over the place and no one seems to be able to find the answer, thanks so much for your help!